The Old Stone Tavern Menu (Updated September 2025)

Welcome to The Old Stone Tavern, a charming restaurant nestled at 758 South Ave, Rochester, NY. Known for its hearty plates and vibrant atmosphere, this local gem captivates both casual diners and food enthusiasts alike. As you step inside, the rustic wooden furnishings and cozy booths invite you to relax and unwind.

Let's talk about the menu — a treasure trove of bold flavors and generous portions. The Huge Plates section highlights favorites like the Steak Burger Plate, featuring a ½ lb juicy burger atop mac salad and fries, crowned with savory toppings for just $16.95. The 2Dogs Plate is a must-try, offering delicious hot dogs served over mac salad and tots for $14.50. If you're craving something lighter, the wrap options, including the Buffalo Chicken Wrap and Bacon Turkey Club Wrap, are bursting with flavor and satisfaction.

Adventurous palates will also enjoy the Taco offerings, especially the Crispy Fish Tacos—three delightful bites that evoke a fresh and zesty experience for $14.50. Feedback from patrons like Jeanette and Takoda highlights not only the quality of the dishes but also the attentive service that makes every meal a special occasion. So whether you're stopping by for a casual meal with friends or a cozy dinner date, The Old Stone Tavern promises to deliver unforgettable culinary delights.